Name: The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever
Prep time: 15 min
Cook time: 10 min
Total time: 35 min
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 6 Large Eggs; 1/4 cup Mayonnaise; 2 tbsp Greek Yogurt; 3 tsp Dijon Mustard; 1 tsp Fresh Lemon Juice; 1/2 tsp Lemon Zest; 1/4 tsp Smoked Paprika; 1/2 tsp Kosher Salt; Black Pepper, to taste; 1/4 cup Spanish Cooking Onion or Shallot, finely diced; 1 tbsp Chives or Scallions, chopped; 1 tbsp Bread & Butter Pickles, finely diced; Bread, sliced; Fresh Lettuce (such as Romaine)

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

If you have ever longed for a classic comfort food that feels both nostalgic and irresistibly fresh, look no further than The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever. This sandwich is not just any egg salad; it’s a luscious blend of perfectly cooked eggs, tangy pickles, and a tangy-yet-smooth dressing that creates a creamy texture that will keep you coming back for more. Whether it’s a busy weekday lunch or a lazy weekend treat, this egg salad sandwich bursts with flavor and texture in every bite, making it an instant favorite that’s surprisingly easy to whip up.

The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever - Recipe Image

Ingredients You’ll Need

The beauty of The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever lies in its simple yet thoughtfully chosen ingredients. Each component plays a vital role, from the silky mayonnaise and Greek yogurt layering creaminess to the sharp Dijon mustard and fresh lemon bringing brightness and balance. These essentials come together harmoniously to make the flavors pop, so let’s dive in.

6 Large Eggs: Hard-boiled for that perfectly firm, creamy texture that forms the sandwich’s base.
1/4 cup Mayonnaise: Adds rich creaminess and smoothness to every bite.
2 tbsp Greek Yogurt: Introduces a subtle tang while keeping the salad light and luscious.
3 tsp Dijon Mustard: Offers a gentle kick with a subtle spicy depth that elevates the flavor profile.
1 tsp Fresh Lemon Juice: Brings bright acidity to cut through the richness effortlessly.
1/2 tsp Lemon Zest: Adds delicate citrus aroma and a fresh burst of flavor to brighten the dish.
1/4 tsp Smoked Paprika: Imparts a smoky warmth that surprises the palate beautifully.
1/2 tsp Kosher Salt: Essential for seasoning and enhancing every ingredient in the salad.
Black Pepper: Freshly ground for a hint of sharpness and complexity.
1/4 cup Spanish Cooking Onion or Shallot, finely diced: Adds a mild crunch and subtle zing that blends perfectly.
1 tbsp Chives or Scallions, chopped: Fresh herbs that bring a bright oniony note and color contrast.
1 tbsp Bread & Butter Pickles, finely diced: Sweet and tangy crunch that balances the creamy texture spectacularly.
Bread and Lettuce: For serving, select your favorite sliced bread and crisp lettuce like Romaine for fresh crunch.

How to Make The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever

Step 1: Perfectly Hard-Boil Your Eggs

Start by hard-boiling six large eggs until the yolks are fully cooked but still moist and creamy — no dry or chalky yolks here. Once boiled, gently peel and chop the eggs into bite-sized pieces that will blend smoothly without losing their satisfying texture in the salad.

Step 2: Mix the Creamy Dressing

In a medium bowl, whisk together the mayonnaise, Greek yogurt, Dijon mustard, fresh lemon juice, lemon zest, smoked paprika, kosher salt, and several grinds of black pepper. This combination is what makes The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever truly luxurious: the mayo and yogurt balance tanginess with richness, while lemon and paprika brighten the whole mix.

Step 3: Incorporate Aromatics and Crunch

Add the finely diced Spanish cooking onion or shallot to the dressing, stirring it in evenly. This gives a subtle sharpness and a touch of crunch. Then gently fold in the chopped eggs, chives or scallions, and bread & butter pickles, making sure every piece is coated without mashing the eggs too much.

Step 4: Chill and Season

Cover the bowl with plastic wrap and let the egg salad chill in the refrigerator for about 20 minutes. This step is crucial because it lets the flavors meld beautifully. Before assembling your sandwiches, give the salad a good stir and adjust seasoning with extra salt, pepper, or lemon juice to suit your taste.

How to Serve The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever

Garnishes

Enhance your sandwich by adding a few leaves of tender Romaine or butter lettuce directly onto your bread, which adds delightful crunch and freshness. A sprinkle of extra chopped chives or a dash of smoked paprika on top of the egg salad gives an inviting pop of color and flavor that makes the sandwich not only taste amazing but look irresistible too.

Side Dishes

Pair The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever with some crunchy dill pickles or a light cucumber salad tossed with vinegar and a touch of dill for a refreshing balance. Crisp vegetable chips or a handful of cherry tomatoes also complement the creamy richness perfectly, rounding out your meal with multiple textures and bursts of flavor.

Creative Ways to Present

Take your sandwiches beyond the traditional by serving them open-faced on toasted artisan bread, allowing the vibrant colors of the egg salad to stand out. You can also turn the salad into elegant lettuce wraps for a low-carb option or spoon it onto crackers for a charming appetizer at your next gathering. Each presentation offers a new way to enjoy the same beloved creamy egg salad.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

If you have any leftover egg salad, store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator where it will stay fresh for up to 3 days. Keep in mind it’s best enjoyed chilled and freshly stirred before serving again to preserve that creamy texture and bright flavor.

Freezing

The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever does not freeze well because the mayonnaise and yogurt base can separate, and the egg texture can change after thawing. It’s best to enjoy this egg salad fresh or within a few days refrigerated rather than frozen.

Reheating

Since this sandwich is best served cold or at room temperature, reheating is not recommended. Simply take the chilled egg salad out of the fridge and let it sit at room temperature for about 10 minutes before assembling or serving to bring out the flavors even more.

FAQs

Can I use regular yogurt instead of Greek yogurt?

You can substitute regular yogurt, but Greek yogurt’s thicker texture contributes to that dreamy creaminess in The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever, so it’s worth seeking out if you can.

Is it possible to make this egg salad vegan?

While this recipe relies on real eggs and dairy, you could experiment with mashed tofu and vegan mayo to mimic the texture, but the classic creaminess and flavor would be quite different.

What type of bread works best for these sandwiches?

Soft sandwich bread, such as classic white, whole wheat, or even brioche, works wonderfully. Choose a bread that will support the creamy filling without overwhelming it.

Can I add other mix-ins to the egg salad?

Absolutely! Some enjoy adding celery for extra crunch, avocado for richness, or herbs like dill for a fresh herbal note. Just remember to maintain that perfect balance that makes this version the creamiest.

How do I avoid a watery egg salad?

Draining any excess moisture from your pickles and using Greek yogurt instead of regular yogurt will help keep The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever perfectly creamy and never watery.

Final Thoughts

There is something truly special about The Creamiest Egg Salad Sandwich Ever. It’s the kind of recipe that feels like a warm hug from your kitchen—a simple yet flavor-packed delight you’ll want to make again and again. Give it a try and watch how this humble sandwich elevates your lunch game and satisfies cravings with every luxurious bite.